It shouldn't matter who is telling you they are FIL. It should be who you like the most. It's not like nobody has ever lied on this show about how they feel to get further.
Nothing like having them all living together during FDs. This is the first time I agree with VF ... awkward! Even more awkward is Peter coming to pick up HA. Let's see if he brings her back in the morning.
You could be the juiciest, most ripe peach, but there is still going to be someone who doesn't like peaches.